Working in an open office: masking chatter

In an open office the problem is speech you can understand: lab studies show it disrupts memory and verbal work even when you try to ignore it. Over headphones, play a steady, wordless sound in the middle of the voice range, such as pink or green noise, rain or the sea, just loud enough that nearby talk becomes a murmur. Noise-cancelling headphones help with the low hum but not much with voices. Save reading, writing and memorising for quiet hours or rooms, and keep the volume at half or lower.

Study Hall

Focus, ocean, 45 min

Why chatter is the hardest noise

A humming air vent is easy to forget. A colleague two desks away talking about their weekend is not, and it is not a lack of willpower. Your brain processes speech it can understand whether you choose to or not.

Two lines of research make this precise:

  • A 2020 review of 14 laboratory studies linked performance to how intelligible background speech was. Performance began to fall once speech was even slightly intelligible and kept falling as it got clearer. Verbal short-term memory tasks were the most strongly and consistently affected.
  • A 2012 study of open-plan office noise compared tasks in quiet and with irrelevant speech. Tasks that relied on short-term memory and rehearsing material, such as remembering and searching for information, were the most disrupted. The author concluded such tasks are poorly suited to rooms where irrelevant speech is constant.

A wider 2011 meta-analysis of 242 studies agrees on the general point: the type of noise and the type of task decide how much noise matters.

How masking helps

The key insight from that research: what hurts is not the loudness of speech but its intelligibility. If a steady sound makes nearby talk harder to understand, it does less damage even at the same volume. Offices with built-in sound masking systems work this way: they add a soft, even background so voices blur into a murmur.

You can do a personal version over headphones:

  • Choose a steady, wordless sound with energy where voices are: the middle of the range. Pink or green noise, rain, or the sea.
  • Set it during conversation. Turn it up until nearby talk becomes a murmur you cannot follow, then stop. You are blurring words, not drowning them.
  • Keep it low. Half volume or lower. You will wear it for hours.

Press play above for Study Hall: the sea through the windows over a soft green-noise bed, with no beat, made to cover voices. It is free in full.

Noise cancelling: good, not enough

Active noise cancelling is very effective against steady low sound such as air conditioning, traffic and the building’s hum. It is less effective against voices, which are higher and change constantly. Noise cancelling plus a low masking sound is a strong combination: the headphones remove the hum, the sound blurs the voices, and you can keep both low.

Plan your tasks around the room

Masking reduces the harm; it does not remove it. Use the time and space you have:

  • Quiet hours (early, late, lunchtimes) for reading, writing and anything you must remember.
  • Busy hours for email, meetings, routine tasks and anything that does not rely on holding words in your head.
  • A quiet room or booth when you have one, for the hardest thinking.
  • Ask. A shared agreement about calls at desks helps everyone.

Sound for deep work covers longer sessions, and how sound masking works explains the acoustics.

Look after your ears

Wearing headphones all day adds up. Cleveland Clinic’s audiologist suggests about half volume or lower for earbuds worn for hours in bed, and the same rule suits a long day at a desk. Take them off in breaks, and turn on any listening-level limit your phone has. If voices leave you turning the volume up and up, the room needs a different solution, not a louder sound.

Where Nightjar helps, and where it doesn’t

Focus blocks run for 25, 50 or 90 minutes, or open-ended. Tune turns any sound down on its own, even parts of a track: the thunder apart from the rain, the saxophone apart from the piano. A volume cap is on by default, and Nightjar is not for infants. Study Hall’s green-noise bed is there for voices; the sea on top gives it something softer than plain noise to sit in.

Nightjar cannot make a colleague’s call less interesting. Masking blurs speech; it does not make an open office as good as a quiet room for hard reading or writing. The research is clear that quiet is better for those tasks, so plan for it where you can.

Sources

  1. Jahncke, Open-plan office noise: the susceptibility and suitability of different cognitive tasks for work in the presence of irrelevant speech, Noise and Health, 2012
  2. Haapakangas and colleagues, The relation between the intelligibility of irrelevant speech and cognitive performance: a revised model based on laboratory studies, Indoor Air, 2020
  3. Szalma and Hancock, Noise effects on human performance: a meta-analytic synthesis, Psychological Bulletin, 2011
  4. Cleveland Clinic, Is It OK To Sleep With Earbuds In? (8 April 2026)

Last checked 13 November 2026.

Questions

What is sound masking in an office?

Adding a steady, soft background sound so that nearby speech is harder to understand. Laboratory studies tie the harm of office chatter to how intelligible it is, so making speech less clear, even without making it quieter, reduces the disruption.

Do noise-cancelling headphones block office chatter?

Partly. Active noise cancelling works best on steady low sounds like air conditioning. Voices get through more, which is why many people play a soft masking sound under noise cancelling.

Is it bad to wear headphones at work all day?

At a low level, with breaks, most people are fine. Keep the volume at half or lower, take them off in breaks, and let your ears rest. If you notice ringing or muffled hearing after work, turn it down.