A white noise machine vs an app on your phone

A fan-based machine such as Yogasleep's Dohm is simple, needs no phone or app, and makes one steady sound from a real fan with no loops, for a one-off price. An app such as Nightjar gives you many sounds, a timer that fades and control over each part of a track, but it needs your phone by the bed.

Nightjar’s makers wrote this page, and Nightjar is one of the apps it describes, so read it with that in mind. The machine we use as an example is Yogasleep’s Dohm Classic, from its product page read on 13 Nov 2026; other machines differ.

What a machine does well

One job, done simply. The Dohm Classic has “A real internal fan” that “creates continuous, natural sound. No audio files, no loops, no speakers.” Two speeds and a twist of the housing to change the tone. You plug it in and leave it.

No phone in the bedroom. No notifications, no screen, no battery to watch. For some people that alone is worth it.

No loops. A fan-based machine makes its sound mechanically, so there is no recording to repeat.

Built to last, at a known price. Yogasleep says it has made the Dohm since 1962, lists the Classic at USD 49.99 with a 30-night trial and a one-year warranty, and says it is assembled by hand in the USA.

Where a machine falls short

One sound. A fan is a fan. If you want rain, the sea or brown noise on different nights, a single fan machine will not give you that.

No timer. Yogasleep’s page for the Dohm Classic lists none.

Another thing to carry. Yogasleep sells a travel case, but on a trip your phone is already with you.

Volume. Machines can be loud. A 2014 study measured 14 infant sleep machines at full volume: all were over 50 dBA at 30 cm, and three were over 85 dBA. The same caution applies to a phone on a pillow.

A machine and an app side by side

Fan-based machine (Dohm Classic) Nightjar
How the sound is made A real fan; no audio files, no loops Nightjar makes its sound live on the iPhone: none of it is a recording and none of it loops.
Sounds One fan sound, two speeds, adjustable tone 92 tracks and 70 single sounds
Timer None listed 5 minutes to 10 hours, Likely asleep or Keep playing
Control Speed and tone Tune turns any sound down on its own, even parts of a track: the thunder apart from the rain, the saxophone apart from the piano.
Volume Set by speed and the housing A volume cap is on by default, and Nightjar is not for infants.
Phone needed No Yes, iPhone only, iOS 26 or later
Pictures None Every track has a moving cover drawn live, and in the player the picture moves with the sound and rests when you pause.
Cost USD 49.99 once Free tier and Nightjar Plus; no prices yet

When an app is the better choice

You want different sounds on different nights. A fan one night, rain on a window the next, brown noise for a hotel room.

You want it to stop by itself. The sleep timer runs from 5 minutes to 10 hours, or Likely asleep, or Keep playing, and the sound fades out gently.

You want the sound to follow the room. With Adapts to your room, the noise bed rises only when the room gets louder, then settles; the microphone is read for level only and nothing is recorded, stored or sent.

You want to try before you buy anything. Free: all 70 single sounds, seven tracks in full, two minutes of any other track, the sleep timer, Discover and playlists, widgets and check-ins, two themes and three nights of adaptive masking. You can also hear white noise on this site now.

When a machine is the better choice

If you want a steady sound every night with no decisions, no screen and no phone beside you, a fan-based machine is hard to beat, and it never needs an update. Both work the same way where it matters: steady sound can cover noises that might wake you. A 2021 review of 38 studies rated the evidence that continuous noise improves sleep itself as very low certainty, so pick whichever you will actually use, and keep it quiet. See white noise vs a fan for how the two sounds differ.

Where Nightjar helps, and where it doesn’t

Nightjar helps if one sound is not enough, if you want a timer that fades, or if you travel and would rather not pack a machine. Its fan is free, and none of its sounds loops.

It does not help if you want your phone out of the bedroom, or a device with no screen and no software at all. It is not for infants; a machine used for a baby needs the same care with volume and distance.

Sources

  1. Yogasleep, Dohm Classic product page, read 13 Nov 2026
  2. Hugh and colleagues, Infant sleep machines and hazardous sound pressure levels, Pediatrics, 2014
  3. Riedy and colleagues, Noise as a sleep aid: a systematic review, Sleep Medicine Reviews, 2021

Last checked 13 November 2026.

Questions

Is a white noise machine better than an app?

Neither is better for everyone. A machine is simpler and keeps your phone away from the bed; an app gives you more sounds, a timer and finer control. What matters most for sleep is a steady sound at a moderate level, which both can give.

How loud can white noise machines get?

Loud enough to matter. A 2014 study measured 14 infant sleep machines at full volume: all were over 50 dBA at 30 cm, and three were over 85 dBA. Keep any machine or phone well away from your head and the volume low. A volume cap is on by default, and Nightjar is not for infants.

Does Nightjar have a fan sound?

Yes. Fan is one of its single sounds, free to play, and you can hear it on this site. Nightjar's sounds are made live, so there is no loop, as with a real fan.